Less than a week later I see a $14.95 charge on my bank account from CIC TripleAdvantage. This is a supposed credit watch service. It is in fact run by Experian. I did not catch in the fine print that I was signing up for a service. If you google the above name you will see tons of stories about people getting taken advantage of.
Here is a site that explains how to try to get your money back.
I was stupid and I was duped. Never cut corners with reading the terms when you're putting sensitive info in. *sigh*